Project factsheet information
|Project Title||A Peering Strategy for the Pacific Islands|
|Full name and acronym||Telco2 Limited|
27 Austin Street, Mount Victoria, Wellington 6011, New Zealand
|Dates covered by this report:||30-11-2016 – 30-11-2019 –|
|Report submission date||30-11-2019|
|Country where project was implemented||New Zealand|
|Project leader name||Jonathan Brewer|
|Project Team||Jonathan Brewer|
|Total budget approved||44,600 AUD|
Many telecommunications networks in the Pacific interconnect not directly but via international carriers in the United States or Australia. This has a profound impact on both the cost and the performance of regional traffic. While web traffic is slowed, real-time collaborations are rendered unusable, creating barriers for inter-island collaboration.
Governments, competitive carriers, Internet societies, and activists argue that direct interconnection, or peering, is the answer to these performance problems. They believe that if competitive networks are allowed to exchange traffic free-of-charge with incumbent networks, the cost of Internet will go down, and performance will go up.
Incumbent networks throughout the Pacific steadfastly refuse to openly peer with other carriers, education networks, and government networks – and a change in this behaviour is not in sight. Not only do they refuse to peer, they sometimes charge their competitors more for direct access to their networks than competitors pay for global Internet connectivity. Competitors, activists, and even governments say this is a clear violation of network neutrality. This project investigating carrier interconnections in the Pacific has shown the situation to be far more nuanced.
This project's objective was to share research collected during an earlier iteration of the project via the web in a dynamic way. This included information on physical and routed topologies, telecommunications market data, and information on the relationships Pacific Island nations have with the rest of the world.
In support of these objectives, the project has produced a website that reviews the telecommunications environment of the Pacific Islands. The site looks at each market's connectivity to the world: telecommunications, sea freight, air routes, and trade. It provides real-time statistics on carrier market share. Finally, it considers the complexity of island telecommunications through a composite case study on peering.
Table of Contents
|Project factsheet information|
|Background and Justification|
|Gender Equality and Inclusion|
|Project Communication Strategy|
|Recommendations and Use of Findings|
Background and Justification:[Back to table of contents]
When the project started, most telecommunications networks in the Pacific interconnected in Asia, Australia, or the United States. This had a profound impact on both the cost and the performance of regional traffic. It discouraged regional interactions, and in particular erected barriers to research and education.
Many stakeholders in the Pacific did not fully understand the impact overseas interconnection had. Few looked beyond the problems of their own country or organisation. This lack of understanding perpetuated cost and performance problems for all users. In some cases, it significantly lessened the impact of new submarine cable infrastructure.
Several cases illustrate the difficulties of the Pacific.
- Most Samoan traffic between providers and universities routes via the United States. Technical workers at three providers and two universities are interested in establishing an exchange. Workshops were held by ISOC, and equipment for the exchange donated by NSRC. No progress in turning the exchange on has been made since equipment was delivered in 2015.
- Samoa's closest political and commercial ties are to New Zealand and Australia. When its new submarine cable to Fiji was built, a decision was made by the Samoa Submarine Cable Corporation to purchase connectivity directly to the United States on the Southern Cross Cable, as it offered the cheapest "Internet" connectivity. This has resulted in all AU/NZ traffic routing from Fiji, to Oregon, to Los Angeles, before travelling back across the Pacific to get to Australia and New Zealand.
- Vanuatu was for a time the Pacific's only success story for keeping local traffic local. The Vanuatu Exchange launched around the same time as a submarine fibre cable connected the country to Fiji. It was a tremendous help to the speed and resilience of Vanuatu’s Internet, but was politically unpopular due to its lowering traffic requirements on the country’s sole submarine cable – a cable partly owned by the government. A regulatory ruling, interference by the government with the regulator, then court action against the government have all been a part of Vanuatu's peering story.
This project sought to promote better understanding of both the requirements for and the availibility of telecommunications infrastructure and operators. Its methods included:
- eductaion on the commercial, technical, and performance issues that accompany overseas interconnections.
- cataloging of demand for communications via identifying island nations' trading partners
- mapping of infrastructure in the form of submarine cables, air routes, and shipping routes
- cataloging operators and the development of infrastructure throughout the region
Project Implementation:[Back to table of contents]
While earlier phases of the project involved tens of collaborators across multiple countries, this phase of the project was entirely focussed on technical implementation. During the first phase of the project the needs of the beneficiary community were assessed via direct interviews. In this stage the final product was designed around their needs. As needs were already assessed, only a small team of implementers was required to unlock collected data and knowledge and present it in an easy-to-consume fashion.
Major project activities and a timeline of when they were executed are presented below.
No schema existed.
Database schema was created, implemented in development and production, and documented in Confluence.
11-2016 through 6-2017
Further development may occur to provide for any new functionality desired. No further development is required to achieve project goals.
Measurements existed across a large number of disparate systems.
Measurement aggregation was implemented.
A single repository of measurements exists in an Amazon Relational Database Service (RDS) instance in Sydney.
Island Relationship visualisations
No other visualisations existed.
Visualisations of economic data that are dynamically updated on an annual basis have been created and put into production.
1-2017 through 3-2017
Monthly programs run on an automatic basis to pull in any new data relevant to how Pacific Island economies interact with the rest of the world have not pulled in recent data. They must be investigated and repaired to ensure the latest data is available online.
Market Size calculations
Existing market estimates available via APNIC were very inaccurate due to a measurement system based on ASN.
Python code and metadata tables were written, tested, and deployed.
1-2017 through 9-2019
Metadata tables allowing the share calculations must be manually curated to allow for new market entrants and consolidation of existing operators. This activity will be ongoing throughout the project.
|Submarine Fibre Maps||Rough maps showing connections were prepared in 2016. Environmental and construction documents existed detailing actual fibre paths and distances.||New fibre paths with accurate distance/latency measurements were created and uploaded to the Carto GIS platform.||8-2018 through 9-2018||All cables are live in Carto. New maps must be ported into the beta Pacpeer website with a code change.|
|New Submarine Cable Maps||Maps through 2018 were current in Carto but not live on the main website.||New maps were added for new cables deployed in 2018-2019. The main website's code was updated to reference the new maps.||6-2019 through 8-2019||All cables are live on the new website.|
|Knowledge Base||A private knowledge base had hundreds of documents in a format accessible only to authenticated researchers||A public knowledge base was created with details on all submarines and carriers referenced by the website. Links were made from the website to the knowledge base.||5-2019 through 9-2019||Knowledge base is live and available for public use.|
|Production Infrastructure||Applications ran on a set of development servers with a local data store.||All database tables were migrated to Amazon's cloud RDS. The web application was migrated to a Telco2 production web server. A Content Delivery Network was installed in front of the web server.||8-2019 through 9-2019||Production website is live at https://connectedpacific.org Prior URLs including beta.pacpeer.org redirect to this site.|
Some project outputs deserve illustration and explanation, and are discussed below.
Island relationship visualisations are made from data drawn via API from the Observatory of Economic Complexity at oec.world. Visualisations of imports and exports from the Solomon Islands are shown below, and clearly show that the Americas don't figure in the important economic relationships of the country, and Europe is represented only by Italy. To procure the best telecommunications products for its businesses, Solomon Islands telecoms providers should be looking to carriers with good connectivity to Asia, not Los Angeles.
Market size calculations allow the public to understand the competitiveness of Pacific telecommunications markets. Calculations on the site are produced daily, based on a 90 day rolling average of advertisements served on Google products by the research team at APNIC. While not perfect, the calculations are a reasonable approximation of commercial market share. The following two charts show an incumbent-dominated market in the Solomon Islands, followed by better balanced market in Guam.
Submarine fibre maps are a source of great confusion in the Pacific and around the world. Organisations like Telegeography and the ITU publish maps which include speculative cable projects and/or cables that have been retired from service. These maps are used by journalists, researchers, and government officials in articles, papers, and decision making processes that are negatively affected by poor quality information.
The current live version of the ITU's public submarine cable map shows a number of non-existant cables below, inlcuding a speculative cable from Perth to the Middle East, a cable from Perth to Singapore that's been cut and is not functional, a dedicated cable from Sydney to the Solomon Islands that doesn't exist, and multiple connections between Papua New Guinea and Indonesia where none exist.
Maps published on the Connected Pacific website have been made as accurate as possible, and only show international submarine cables that are in active use or build. Taking into account accurate information, a company in Papua New Guinea seeking interconnction with a company in Indonesia would know the only current routes are via Australia or Asia, and that performance is likely to be poor due to the lack of direct interconnection between the countries.
The project's accompanying knowledge base provides a vast amount of detail on many pieces of Pacific infrastructure, including commercial, regulatory, financial, technical, and environmental documents where available. It's designed in a manner that will allow future collaborators to expand existing entries and add new ones.
Project Evaluation:[Back to table of contents]
This section of the paper evaluates the implementation of the project.
- To what extend the project achieved its objectives?
- Most objectives have been achieved. A live website provides data on all Pacific island nations and their telecommunications environments.
- Hundreds of background documents on the region's cable systems are available in one place for the first time.
- Statistics from hosting provider CloudFlare show the site is used daily and has reached thousands of users.
- What contribution to development did the project make?
- Telecommunications providers throughout the Pacific are aware of the project, and the issues of poor interconnections.
- The project and its blog posts are frequently mentioned in regional media and mailing lists.
- Peering exchanges in Fiji, Guam, and Papua New Guinea encouraged by the project have been successfully established.
- Is there evidence of positive impact?
- Fiji and PNG both have operational Internet Exchanges as of 2018, in part due to evidence-based lobbying encouraged by this project.
- In Guam major operators are peering at a neutral exchange for the first time in part due to an intervention by this project.
- To what extent the project delivered benefits/outcomes that support gender equality, diversity and inclusion?
- Information is priviliged in Pacific society and often held tightly by those in power. There's no culture of sharing information, especially when it comes to financing details around large national and regional projects. This project amalgamates and opens up large amounts of telecommunications information to activists, researchers, governments, and competitive providers, and helps to level the playing field for those seeking change.
- To what extent has the project lived to its potential for growth/further development?
- Statistics from hosting provider CloudFlare show the project receives around 1,600 unique users per month.
- The Pacific Community has offered a Memorandum of Understanding expressing their desire to continue and potentially host the project going forward.
- To what extent do the proposed activities support the development of local technical capacity in a gender equality and inclusion framework?
- If the project is managed by the Pacific Community in the future, all participants will benefit from their development and inclusion policies.
- What were the most important findings and outputs of the project?
- Good information on Pacific infrastructure and networks is scarce, and sharing such information openly is of value to the community.
- What will be done with them?
- Outputs of the project will be available indefinitely. With the cooperation of the Pacific Community, new outputs may continue to be developed.
- To what extend the project help build up the capacity of your institution or of the individuals involved?
- The project leader has learned new coding and GIS skills, and hopes to transfer much of this knowledge to future collaborators.
- Were certain aspects of project design, management and implementation particularly important to the degree of success of the project?
- The decision to use software-as-a-service platforms including Carto, Confluence, Amazon RDS, and CloudFlare have enabled a very small team to produce a very technically involved web resource with a relatively small budget.
|Indicators||Baseline||Project activities related to indicator||Outputs and outcomes||Status|
|How do you measure project progress, linked to the your objectives and the information reported on the Implementation and Dissemination sections of this report.||Refers to the initial situation when the projects haven’t started yet, and the results and effects are not visible over the beneficiary population.||Refer to how the project has been advancing in achieving the indicator at the moment the report is presented. Please include dates.||We understand change is part of implementing a project. It is very important to document the decision making process behind changes that affect project implementation in relation with the proposal that was originally approved.||Indicate the dates when the activity was started. Is the activity ongoing or has been completed? If it has been completed add the completion dates.|
Accessible Project Research & Data
Project research data was only available via powerpoint presentations and technical grant reports.
Project activities are discussed in detail in the implementation section.
A functional, well publicised, and well used website is available for members of the community to interact with.
|Project begun 2016-11 and completed 2019-11|
Gender Equality and Inclusion:[Back to table of contents]
Although this phase of the project had no specific goals for diversity, the intial project team listed in the website's credits, was gender and ethnically diverse. All team members learned more about the project topic and a host of cloud informatics platforms.
Project Communication Strategy:[Back to table of contents]
This project is essentially a communication strategy for a previous research project. The research and the Connected Pacific website have been promoted in several conference talks, on the APNIC blog, and on the PICISOC email list. The latter list is highly ethnically, gender, age, and socio-economically diverse. Participants include students, members of civil society, government officials, incumbent carriers, competitive carriers, and start-up ISPs – all potential beneficiaries of the work.
Through various communications, beneficiaries have contacted the project leader and has provided pro-bono assistance on matters relating to social media servers in Fiji, community networks in Vanuatu, satellite links in the Solomon islands and Niue, transit arrangements in Tonga, terrestrial fibre networks in Kiribati, and a peering exchange in Guam.
In addition to anecdotal data on contacts and projects, measurable data showing the reach and use of the site is available from its hosting provider CloudFlare. In the last month the project site had 1,716 unique visitors.
Recommendations and Use of Findings:[Back to table of contents]
For creation of and sharing of knowledge, Atlassian's Confluence tool was an excellent choice. For a token annual fee it allows multiple collaborators (up to ten) to work on a wiki rich media, access control, revision control, and an API. That API allows non-technical participants to produce content that's included by API in the dynamic site. For a research project involving only static or manually updated data, Confluence could be the only tool used.
The Pacific Community's nascent data hub project has been identified as a potential beneficiary of the project, and future keeper of the project's data. With the technical framework of the project ready, their deep connections into Pacific communities could help identify future participants in the project who might add information to the knowledge base, or integrate data from the project in their own work.
Bibliography:[Back to table of contents]
Aben, E. (2015, July 2). Improving RIPE Atlas Coverage – Which Networks Are Missing?. Ripe NCC. Retrieved from https://labs.ripe.net/Members/emileaben/improving-ripe-atlas-coverage-what-networks-are-missing
Aben, E. (2015, March 23). Measuring Countries and IXPs with RIPE Atlas. Ripe NCC. Retrieved from https://labs.ripe.net/Members/emileaben/measuring-ixps-with-ripe-atlas
Anderson, P. K., & Suwamaru, J. K. (2011). PPC-1 Sydney-Guam PIPE pacific cable: New internet gateway for PNG via Madang. Contemporary PNG Studies, 15, 1 – 20.
Angwin, J., & Larson, J. (2015, August 15). A Trail of Evidence Leading to AT&T’s Partnership with the NSA. ProPublica. Retrieved from https://www.propublica.org/article/a-trail-of-evidence-leading-to-atts-partnership-with-the-nsa
Asian Development Bank. (2015). North Pacific Regional Connectivity Investment Project: Report and Recommendation of the President (Project Number: 46382-001). Retrieved from https://www.adb.org/projects/documents/pal-north-pacific-regional-connectivity-investment-project-rrp
Asian Development Bank. (2016). North Pacific Regional Connectivity Investment Project: Procurement Plan (Project Number: 46382-001). Retrieved from https://www.adb.org/projects/documents/pal-north-pacific-regional-connectivity-investment-project-pp
AT&T. (2016). Global Network Latency Averages. ipnetwork. Retrieved from https://ipnetwork.bgtmo.ip.att.net/pws/global_network_avgs.html
Audio Productions, Inc. (Producer). (2011, March 3). C.S Long Lines [Video file]. AT&T Archives and History Center, Warren, NJ. Retrieved from http://techchannel.att.com/play-video.cfm/2011/3/21/AT&T-Archives-CS-Longlines
Australia Japan Cable (n.d). Guam Landing Points. Retrieved from http://www.ajcable.com/guam-landing-points/
Bagnol, R. C. (2013, July 22). IT&E: We’re not a monopoly. Marianas Variety. Retrieved from http://www.mvariety.com/cnmi/cnmi-news/local/57646-it-e-we-re-not-a-monopoly
Bakhshi, B., Manna, M., Mohs, G., Kovsh, D. I., Lynch, R. L., Vaa, M., … & Jiang, S. (2004). First dispersion-flattened transpacific undersea system: From design to terabit/s field trial. Journal of lightwave technology, 22(1), 233.
Barnett, W. C., Takahira, H., Baroni, J. C., & Ogi, Y. (1996). The TPC – 5 Cable Network. IEEE Communications, 36 – 40.
Bejado, C. Y. (2010, January 17). GTA TeleGuam Expands Capacity for Trans-Pacific Communications. Business Wire. Retrieved from http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20100117005007/en/GTA-TeleGuam-Expands-Capacity-Trans-Pacific-Communications
Botha, G. D (2014). In the Appeal of Pacific Data Systems Inc. Guam: Office of Public Accountability.
Bressie, K. (2009). Cable Landing License Held by Tyco Telecommunications (US) Inc., FCC File No. SCL-LIC-20050304-00011. Wiltshire & Grannis, Washington, USA.
Bressie, K. (2014). PTC'14 Undersea Cable Regulatory Update [Powerpoint Presentation]. Wiltshire & Grannis, 1-11.
Bressie, K. D. (2012). Applications Filed for the Transfer of Control of Wavecom Solutions Corporation to Hawaiian Telcom, Inc. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
Brooks, D. F (2013NOV13). Decision and Order Re Purchasing Agency's Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Guam: Office of Public Accountability.
Brooks, D. F (2013NOV21). In the Appeal of Teleguam Holdings, LLC and its Wholly Owned Subsidaries, GTA Telecom LLC; GTA Services, LLC; and Pulse Mobile, LLC. Guam: Office of Public Accountability.
Brooks, D. F (2015). In the Appeal of Pacific Data Systems Inc. Guam: Office of Public Accountability.
Brooks, D. F. (2013). Procurement Appeals 12-016, 12-017 and 12-018 Consolidated Decisions. Hagåtña, Guam.
Brooks, D. F. (2014). Procurement Appeals OPA – PA – 13 – 016. Hagåtña, Guam.
Brooks, D. F. (2015). Procurement Appeals OPA – PA – 14 – 013. Hagåtña, Guam.
Brumley, R. [Pacific Telecommunications Council]. (2014, March 27). PTC'14 Keynote 2-2 – Laser Light Communications: Bringing the World the Power of Light™ [Video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKKnLy_ewG0
Buckley, S. (2014, January 23). Tata lights up 100G services on TGN-P cable route linking U.S., Asia and Japan. Fierce Telecom. Retrieved from http://www.fiercetelecom.com/telecom/tata-lights-up-100g-services-tgn-p-cable-route-linking-u-s-asia-and-japan
Burger, T. (2015, February 9). How Fast is Realtime? Human Perception and Technology [Web log post]. Retrieved from https://www.pubnub.com/blog/2015-02-09-how-fast-is-realtime-human-perception-and-technology/
Burrington, I. (2015, November 12). Where the Cloud Rises From the Sea. The Atlantic. Retrieved from http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/11/where-the-cloud-rises-from-the-sea/415236/?utm_source=SFTwitter
Cagurangan, M. (2013, April 15). Lawsuits stall GovGuam telecom contract anew. The Guam Daily Post. Retrieved from http://www.postguam.com/news/local/lawsuits-stall-govguam-telecom-contract-anew/article_50d292fa-935c-59fa-8758-75d1cb235d4b.html
Cagurangan, M. (2012, September 2). NTT Docomo to buy MCV. Marianas Variety. Retrieved from http://www.mvariety.com/cnmi/cnmi-news/local/49334-ntt-docomo-to-buy-mcv.php
Calabrese, M., Calarco, D., & Richardson, C. (2012, May 16). The Most Expensive Internet in America [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2012/05/24/internet_access_and_cost_in_american_samoa_northern_marianas_islands_guam_.html
Caldwell, B. (2004, July 7). Grant eyed for new fiber optic cable. Retrieved from http://www.saipantribune.com/index.php/9fe12116-1dfb-11e4-aedf-250bc8c9958e/
Camacho, V., Nishihira, F. S., Camacho, A. R., & Mann, B. R. (2015). Teleguam Holdings, LLC v. Territory of Guam, 2015 Guam 13, Opinion. Hagåtña, Guam: Supreme Court of Guam.
Carlisle, T. (2008). Application for a License to Land and Operate a Private Fiber-Optic Cable System Connecting Australia, Guam, and Papua New Guinea, for the PPC1 System. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
CenturyLink IQ (2011). Networking Service Level Agreement International Private Port Latency Goals attachment 2 (version 1), 1-2.
Clark, N. (2015, September 1). AusNOG 2015: meeting continues to impress [Web log post]. APNIC. Retrieved from https://blog.apnic.net/2015/09/01/ausnog-2015-meeting-continues-to-impress/
Clesca, B. (2014, January 20). Palau Telecoms Selects Xtera for the Turnkey Supply of the Palau – Guam Submarine Cable System [Web log post]. Xtera. Retrieved from http://www.xtera.com/palau-telecoms-selects-xtera-for-the-turnkey-supply-of-the-palau-guam-submarine-cable-system/
Cognet Communications Inc. (2016). IP Network Performance Statistics. Cognet. Retrieved from https://www.cogentco.com/en/network/performance
Commonwealth HealthCare Corporation (2013). Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands State Medicaid Health Information Technology Plan (SMHP) (version 3). Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, USA.
Cooper, T. J. (2014). IPLC QUOTE: 1Gb Full Channel Guam-Hi, Guam LL on AAG. IT & E Life in Motion, 1.
Cousins, M. (2015, September 8). Pacific’s ‘Future Leaders’ Gather in Auckland. U.S Embassy & Consulate in New Zealand. Retrieved from https://nz.usembassy.gov/pacifics-future-leaders-gather-in-auckland/
Cunliffe, F. R., Clark, A. B., Torres, R. J., & Limtiaco, A. A. G. (2002). Carlson v. GTA, Opinion. Hagåtña, Guam: Supreme Court of Guam.
DatacenterDynamics. (2008, January 28). GTA TELEGUAM announces grand opening of the new Asia Pacific Datacenter (APAC). Retrieved from http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/gta-teleguam-announces-grand-opening-of-the-new-asia-pacific-datacenter-apac/55120.fullarticle
Dawson, W. (2000). Affidavit of S. Wallace Dawson, Jr. Federal Communications Commission. Washington, USA.
Day, J. (2015). Notice of Appeal Form Procurement Appeal Pacific Data Systems, Inc. Guam.
di Lallo, R. (2015, August 3). Is It Really Worth Peering at IXPs? A Comparative Study. Ripe NCC. Retrieved from https://labs.ripe.net/Members/roberto_di_lallo/is-it-really-worth-peering-at-ixps
Dumat-ol Daleno, G. (2015, July 11). Undersea cable break offers lessons for Guam, world. Pacific Daily News. Retrieved from http://www.guampdn.com/story/news/2015/07/10/undersea-cable-break-offers-lessons-guam-world/29950811/
Eckel, J. W. (2008). Application for a License to Land and Operate a Private Fiber-Optic Cable System Connecting the U.S. Army Kwajalein Atoll/Reagan Test Site, in the Republic of the Marshall Islands, and Guam for the Hantru1 System. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
Eugenio, H. V. (2010, April 6). IT&E gets $8M ARRA grant. Saipan Tribune. Retrieved from http://recovery.gov.mp/2010/04/ite-gets-8m-arra-grant/
Feagaimaalii-Luamanu, J. (2015, March 3). ASTCA fiber optic and O3b services to begin soon. Retrieved from http://www.samoanews.com/content/en/astca-fiber-optic-and-o3b-services-begin-soon
Federal Communication Commission. (2001). IT&E Overseas, Inc. Petition for Designation as an Eligible Telecommunications Carrier in the Territory of Guam. Federal Register, 6(244), 65502.
Federal Communications Commission (2015). Streamlined Submarine Cable Landing License Applications Accepted for Filing. Washington, USA.
Federal Communications Commission. (2012). Applications Filed For The Transfer Of Control Of Subsidiaries Of Mcv Guam Holding Corp. To Docomo Guam Holding Inc: Comments of One Economy Corporation one Global Economy. Federal Communications Commission. Washington, USA.
Fishman, E., & Bressie, K.D. (2010). Office des Postes et Telecommunications de Polynesie francaise; File Nos. SCL-LIC-20081008-00017 and ITC-214-20081008-0045. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
Glover, B. (2012). History of the Atlantic Cable & Undersea Communications from the first submarine cable of 1850 to the worldwide fiber optic network. Retrieved from http://atlantic-cable.com/Cables/CableTimeLine/index2001.htm
Ha, M. (2016, July 25). AAE-1 undersea cable to operate in Vietnam this year. Retrieved from http://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/science-it/159438/aae-1-undersea-cable-to-operate-in-vietnam-this-year.html
Hart, T. (2011, March 2). Guam broadband use to be mapped, studied. Retrieved http://www.postguam.com/news/local/guam-broadband-use-to-be-mapped-studied/article_1ef24634-315e-5113-9ef8-b11754a8d6c3.html
Hawaii Pacific Teleport (n.d). Satellite Coverage [Graph of possible coverage from HPT teleport via multiple satellites]. Retrieved from http://www.hawaiiteleport.com/index.php/satellite-coverage
Hawaii's Internet access high (n.d). Retrieved from http://archives.starbulletin.com/content/20100219_Hawaiis_Internet_access_high_but_usage_among_nations_lowest
Hayakawa, Rieko. "Self-Determination for the Communication Policy in the Pacific Islands." Self-determinable Development of Small Islands. Springer Singapore, 2016. 179-202.
Heap, S., & Paradis, (2016, July). A world without termination rates – reality or fiction. Retrieved from http://www.hottelecom.com/articles/articles-July-2016.html
Hinirat, A. S. (2012). Revised Bid Status Telecommunication Services. Agana, Guam: General Service Agency.
Ho, D., & Calarco, D. (2013, March 8). Broadband returns to the Guam Public Library System Branches [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://broadbandmapguam.blogspot.co.nz/2013/03/broadband-returns-to-guam-public.html
Holland, E. (2013). Director Pace – SD Professor Elisabeth Holland. Suva, Fiji: The University of the South Pacific.
Horecky, F. J. (2015). Guam Telecom, LLC USAC Certification GT Docket 15-01 PUC Counsel Report. Guam: Guam Public Utilities Commission.
International Cable Protection Committee. (2015, May 21). Scientific Cables. Retrieved from https://iscpc.org/cable-data/scientific-cables/
Internet World Stats. (n.d). Wallis and Futuna Islands Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.internetworldstats.com/pacific.htm#wf
IT & E Life in Motion (2010, June 16). IT&E Increases Asia-Pacific Bandwidth Capacity. Retrieved from https://www.ite.net/news_and_info.cfm?vzid=3
IT & E Life in Motion (2011, January 06). IT&E upgrades quadruples peak load speed. Retrieved from https://www.ite.net/news_and_info.cfm?vzid=5
IT & E Life in Motion (2011, January 26). IT&E on track with infrastructure upgrades using ARRA funds. Retrieved from https://www.ite.net/news_and_info.cfm?vzid=6
Jaynes, B. (2009, November 25). Undersea Fiber Optic Cable Arrives In Pohnpei. Pacific Islands Report. Retrieved from http://archives.pireport.org/archive/2009/november/11-25-09.htm
Kabua, A. (2014). Country Report on IP/ISP Network [PowerPoint Presentation]. Marshall Islands National Telecommunications Authority.
Kuerht, L. (2010). Justification for other than Full and Open Competition NTIA Award #NT10BIX5570053. IT & E Life in Motion, 1-3.
Kuipers, K. (2015, July 27). Analysing the K-root Anycast Infrastructure. Ripe NCC. Retrieved from https://labs.ripe.net/Members/jh_kuipers/analyzing-the-k-root-anycast-infrastructure
La Fibre, (2015). Multinode Deployment Guide, Release. Google Global Cache.
Labour & Immigration Research Centre (2012). Population Movement in the Pacific: A Perspective on Future Prospects. Wellington, New Zealand.
Licanto, N. (2015, October 19). Visitor numbers for Japan fall flat. Retrieved from http://www.kuam.com/story/30290668/2015/10/18/visitor-numbers-for-japan-fall-flat
Madory, D. (2013, OCTOBER 16). Submarine Cables Add Resilience But Paths Still Matter. Dyn Research. http://research.dyn.com/2013/10/subsea-cables-add-resilience/
Manojlovic, V. (2015, July 21). Extending RIPE Atlas' Reach. Ripe NCC. Retrieved from https://labs.ripe.net/Members/becha/extending-ripe-atlas-reach
Metzger, R. J. (2015). Petition Of Teleguam Holdings, Llc To Deny the Application To Transfer Guam Cellular Licenses. Washington, USA : Federal Communications Commission.
Minges, M., & Stork, C. (2015). Economic and Social Impact of ICT in the Pacific. Sydney, Australia: Pacific Region Infrastructure Facility.
Mitchell, R. (2015, August 21). Internet traffic jam in Asia as submarine cable breaks. APNIC. Retrieved from http://blog.apnic.net/2015/08/21/internet-traffic-jam-in-asia-as-submarine-cable-breaks/
National Telecommunications & Information Administration (n.d). Service Providers Public Notice Submission Choice Phone, LLC. Retrieved from http://www2.ntia.doc.gov/node/422
Nguyen, L. (2014). Unsolicited Offer to University of Guam Telecommunications Proposal. University of Guam Endowment Foundation, Guam.
Norton, W. B. (2011). The Internet peering playbook: connecting to the core of the Internet. DrPeering Press.
Pactel International (n.d). RICS Ku-Band. Retrieved from https://web.archive.org/web/20160411011305/http://www.pactelint.com/products/satellite-internet-products.php?RICS-Ku-Band-1
PCCW Global. (2009, June 24). PCCW Global and Tata Communications jointly strengthen connectivity and reliability in Asia Pacific via the TGN-Intra Asia Cable System. Retrieved from https://www.pccwglobal.com/en/about/newsroom/archive/297-pccw-global-and-tata-communications-jointly-strengthen-connectivity-and-reliability-in-asia-pacific-via-the-tgn-intra-asia-cable-system
picisoc. (2015, July 8). [email protected] 2015, Auckland, New Zealand. Retrieved from http://www.picisoc.org/2015/07/08/pacinetnethui-2015-auckland-new-zealand/
Pinaroc, J. D. (2015, August 27). Company Proposes Installing Fiber Cable Connections In CNMI. Pacific Islands Report. Retrieved from http://www.pireport.org/articles/2015/08/27/company-proposes-installing-fiber-cable-connections-cnmi
Poppe, Y. (2009a). Partner and participant in Global R&E networking [PowerPoint Presentation]. TATA Communications.
Poppe, Y. (2009b). Connecting emergent R&E networks and applications at lambda speeds [PowerPoint Presentation]. TATA Communications.
Press Release. (2015, September 3). Docomo plans next steps for possible undersea fiber build. Retrieved from http://www.saipantribune.com/index.php/docomo-plans-next-steps-for-possible-undersea-fiber-build/
Pryke, J. (2014, August 28). Pacific Islanders in Australia: where are the Melanesians?. DevPolicy Blog. Retrieved from http://devpolicy.org/pacific-islanders-in-australia-where-are-the-melanesians-20140828/
Reddy, M., & Ghazali, F. (2010). Final Determination on Prices and Access for Southern Cross Capacity and Network. Suva, Fiji: Commerce Commission.
Reddy, M., Mataitin, L., & Shah, K. (2010). Price and Access Determination For Southern Cross Capacity and Network. Suva, Fiji: Commerce Commission.
Rogers, S. (2013, January 28). Borders and boundaries: 16 Google Fusion border files for you to use. Retrieved from https://simonrogers.net/2013/01/28/borders-and-boundaries-16-google-fusion-border-files-for-you-to-use/
Russell, R. (June, 2015). SOCC 2015/01 :Solomon Islands Submarine Cable System –a network of cables from Honiara to Auki, Noro and Sydney. Asian Development Bank, Sydney Australia.
Sanger, D. E., & Schmitt, E. (2015, October 25). Russian Ships Near Data Cables Are Too Close for U.S. Comfort. NY Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/26/world/europe/russian-presence-near-undersea-cables-concerns-us.html?_r=0
Sea-Me-We3 List Pricings. (2015). [List of pricings based on location].
Senase, J. R. T. (2015, August 8). Palau Misses Chance For High Speed Internet Access Cable. Pacific Islands Report. Retrieved from http://www.pireport.org/articles/2015/08/04/palau-misses-chance-high-speed-internet-access-cable
Shapefiles (n.d). [Maps of various Marine Regions]. Retrieved from http://www.marineregions.org/downloads.php
Snijders, J. (2013). Introduction. NLONG Ring. Retrieved from https://ring.nlnog.net/
Southern Cross Cable Network. (2012). Access & Backhaul. Retrieved from https://www.southerncrosscables.com/#
Starosielski, N., Loyer, E., & Brennan, S. (n.d). Surfacing. Retrieved from http://surfacing.in/
Taitano, C. T. (2016a). Amendment Acknowledgement form RFI 001-2016 Internet Caching Solution Ammendment 1. Barrigada, Guam: Department of Education.
Taitano, C. T. (2016b). Amendment Acknowledgement form RFI 001-2016 Internet Caching Solution Ammendment 2. Barrigada, Guam: Department of Education.
Taitano, C. T. (2016c). Amendment Acknowledgement form RFI 001-2016 Internet Caching Solution Ammendment 2. Barrigada, Guam: Department of Education.
Tatarata, M. (2008). Application for Authority pursuant to Cable Landing License Act 47. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
The University of the South Pacific. (n.d). MOOC on Climate Change and Pacific Islands. Retrieved from http://www.uspmoocpaccc.org/
Tritt, C. (1992). Joint Application for a License to Land and Operate a High Capacity Digital Submarine Cable Network Between and Among the United States Mainland, the State of Hawaii, the Island of Guam and Japan. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
Tritt, C. A. (1993). Application for a license to Land and Operate a High Capacity Digital Submarine Cable System Extending Between the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.
U.S Department of Education (2010). Nearly $83 Million in Recovery Funds Now Available for Guam to Save Jobs and Drive Reform. Retrieved from http://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/nearly-83-million-recovery-funds-now-available-guam-save-jobs-and-drive-reform
U.S Securities and Exchange Commission. (1998). Japan – U.S. Cable Network Construction and Maintenance Agreement. Retrieved from https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1278739/000104746904009653/a2131411zex-10_7.htm
United States District Court. (1990, June 12). IT&E OVERSEAS, INC. v. RCA Global Communications, 747 F. Supp. 6 (D.D.C. 1990), Justia US Law. Retrieved from http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/747/6/1480021/
Unknown. (2015, November 27). Balancing Act – Africa. Issue 805. Retrieved from http://www.balancingact-africa.com/news/issue/telecoms-en/805
Unknown. (2016). DRFortress Peering and connectivity. Retrieved from http://www.drfortress.com/internet-exchange/peering-and-connectivity/
Unknown. (2016). Pacific Community. Retrieved from http://www.spc.int/
Unknown. (2016). Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency (FFA). Retrieved from https://www.ffa.int/
Unknown. (2016). PNG-IXP-Project. Retrieved from http://www.nicta.gov.pg/png-ixp-project
Valemi, R. (2015, December 23). 74m deal. The Fiji Times ONLINE. Retrieved from http://www.fijitimes.com/story.aspx?id=334980.
Verizon (2001). Private Line Service Guam – Saipan Digital Fiber Service.
Verizon (2016). IP Latency Statistics [Statistics of IP Latencies from Verizon Enterprise Solutions]. Retrieved from http://www.verizonenterprise.com/about/network/latency/
Villahermosa, C. A. E. (2015, Septemeber 10). IT&E plan doesn’t impress Leepan. Marianas Variety. Retrieved from http://www.mvariety.com/cnmi/cnmi-news/local/79925-it-e-plan-doesn-t-impress-leepan
Villaverde, R. (2011). Practical information about Guam. Retrieved from http://ns.gov.gu/utilities.html
White, J. (2013, January 22). GovGuams telecom contract still in limbo. The Guam Daily Post. Retrieved http://www.postguam.com/news/local/govguam-s-telecom-contract-still-in-limbo/article_3c5023a2-530d-5ebb-8dfb-e0cb33bf9134.html
Wikipedia. (n.d). Niue: OER Initiatives in Niue. Retrieved from http://poerup.referata.com/wiki/Niue#Internet_in_Niue
Wilson, J. R. (2008). Application for a License to Land and Operate a Private Fibre-Optic Cable System connecting Hawaii, American Somoa and Somoa for the American Somoa-Hawaii Cable. Washington, USA: Federal Communications Commission.